Critical subgroup

This article is about a definition in group theory that is standard among the group theory community (or sub-community that dabbles in such things) but is not very basic or common for people outside.
VIEW: Definitions built on this | Facts about this: (facts closely related to Critical subgroup, all facts related to Critical subgroup) |Survey articles about this | Survey articles about definitions built on this
VIEW RELATED: Analogues of this | Variations of this | Opposites of this |
View a list of other standard non-basic definitions

This article is about a subgroup property related to the Classification of finite simple groups

WARNING: POTENTIAL TERMINOLOGICAL CONFUSION: Please don't confuse this with critical group

Definition

Symbol-free definition

A subgroup of a group of prime power order (or more generally, of a possibly infinite p-group) is termed a critical subgroup if it is characteristic in the whole group and satisfies the following three conditions:

1. The subgroup is a Frattini-in-center group: Its Frattini subgroup is contained in its center.
2. The subgroup is a commutator-in-center subgroup: Its commutator with the whole group is contained in its center.
3. The subgroup is a self-centralizing subgroup: Its centralizer in the whole group is contained in it.

Definition with symbols

Let $G$ be a group of prime power order (or more generally, a possibly infinite p-group).

A subgroup $H$ of $G$ is said to be critical if it is characteristic in $G$, and the following three conditions hold:

1. $\Phi(H) \le Z(H)$, i.e., the Frattini subgroup is contained inside the center (i.e., $H$ is a Frattini-in-center group).
2. $[G,H] \le Z(H)$ (i.e., $H$ is a commutator-in-center subgroup of $G$).
3. $C_G(H)= Z(H)$ (i.e., $H$ is a self-centralizing subgroup of $G$).

Relation with other properties

Stronger properties

• Abelian critical subgroup
• Constructibly critical subgroup
• c-closed critical subgroup

Weaker properties

• Weakly critical subgroup: The same conditions, except that we drop the condition of characteristicity in the whole group.
• Self-centralizing characteristic subgroup
• Self-centralizing normal subgroup
• Commutator-in-center subgroup
• Class two normal subgroup
• Coprime automorphism-faithful subgroup: For full proof, refer: Critical implies coprime automorphism-faithful

Group properties satisfied

Any critical subgroup satisfies the following group properties:

• Frattini-in-center group
• Group of nilpotence class two

Facts

1. Every group of prime power order has a critical subgroup. Further information: Thompson's critical subgroup theorem, Analysis of Thompson's critical subgroup theorem
2. More generally, every infinite p-group that is also abelian-by-nilpotent has a critical subgroup. Further information: Analogue of critical subgroup theorem for infinite abelian-by-nilpotent p-group
3. A group of prime power order can arise as a critical subgroup of some group, if and only if it is a Frattini-in-center group. Further, any Frattini-in-center group is a critical subgroup of itself.
4. A critical subgroup that is also extraspecial as a group must equal the whole group. For full proof, refer: extraspecial and critical implies whole group
5. Abelian Frattini subgroup implies centralizer is critical

Metaproperties

Left realization

A group of prime power order can arise as a critical subgroup of some group, if and only if it is a Frattini-in-center group (in other words, its Frattini subgroup is contained in its center). Further, any Frattini-in-center group is a critical subgroup of itself.

Right realization

By Thompson's critical subgroup theorem, every group of prime power order possesses a critical subgroup.