Characteristically metacyclic and commutator-realizable implies abelian

From Groupprops
Jump to: navigation, search
This article describes a fact or result that is not basic but it still well-established and standard. The fact may involve terms that are themselves non-basic
View other semi-basic facts in group theory
VIEW FACTS USING THIS: directly | directly or indirectly, upto two steps | directly or indirectly, upto three steps|
VIEW: Survey articles about this
This fact is related to the problem of realization related to the following subgroup-defining function: commutator subgroup
Realization problems are usually about which groups can be realized as subgroups/quotients related to a subgroup-defining function.
View other facts related to realization problems for commutator subgroup OR View terminology related to them


Statement with symbols

The statement has two forms:

  1. Suppose G is a Characteristically metacylic group (?): in other words, there exists a cyclic characteristic subgroup K of G such that G/K is also cyclic. Further, suppose that G is a commutator-realizable group: there exists a group H such that [H,H] = G, i.e., G occurs as the commutator subgroup of some group. Then, G is an abelian group.
  2. Suppose G is commutator-realizable, and has a characteristic subgroup such that the quotient is a nontrivial characteristically metacyclic quotient group. Then, that quotient group must be abelian.

A particular case of this is as follows: if G/G' and G'/G'' are both cyclic, and G occurs as the commutator subgroup of some group, then G' = G''.


Facts used

  1. Commutator subgroup is normal
  2. Characteristic of normal implies normal
  3. Commutator subgroup centralizes cyclic normal subgroup
  4. Cyclic over central implies abelian


Proof in the first form

Given: A group H, G = [H,H], and K is a characteristic subgroup of G such that both K and G/K are cyclic.

To prove: G is abelian.


  1. G is normal in H: This is fact (1).
  2. K is normal in H: This follows from facts (2), the fact that K is characteristic in G, and the fact that G is normal in H.
  3. G centralizes K: This follows from fact (3): the commutator subgroup of H (which is G) must centralize the cyclic normal subgroup K.
  4. G is abelian: From the previous step, we obtain that K is central in G. Further, we are given that G/K is cyclic, so by fact (4), we obtain that G is abelian.

Proof in the second form

Given: A group H. G = [H,H]. G has a characteristic subgroup L such that G/L is characteristically metacyclic.

To prove: G/L is abelian.


  1. G is normal in H: This is fact (1).
  2. L is normal in H: This is fact (2), along with the given data that L is characteristic in G and G is normal in H.
  3. G/L = [H/L,H/L], and hence, G/L is realizable as a commutator subgroup: Since both G and H contain L, this follows by the definition of commutator subgroup.

The result now follows by applying the result in its first form to the group G/L.


Textbook references

  • Abstract Algebra by David S. Dummit and Richard M. Foote, 10-digit ISBN 0471433349, 13-digit ISBN 978-0471433347, More info, Page 198, Exercise 18, Section 6.1