Normal subgroup comparable with all normal subgroups implies characteristic in finite group

From Groupprops

Statement

Suppose G is a finite group and H is a normal subgroup of G such that for any normal subgroup <mtah>K</math> of G, either H≤K or K≤H. Then, H is a characteristic subgroup of G.

Related facts

Applications

Breakdown for infinite groups

Proof

Given: A finite group G, a normal subgroup H such that for any normal subgroup K of G, either H≤K or K≤H.

To prove: For any automorphism σ of G, σ(H)=H.

Proof: We observe that:

  • Since G is finite, H is finite.
  • Since H is normal and σ is an automorphism, σ(H) is also normal.
  • Thus, either H≤σ(H) or σ(H)≤H.
  • Since σ(H) is isomorphic to H, H and σ(H) have the same cardinality. Combining this with the previous fact yields that H=σ(H).