Local powering-invariant subgroup containing the center is intermediately powering-invariant in nilpotent group
Statement
Suppose is a nilpotent group and is a subgroup containing the center of that is also a local powering-invariant subgroup of . Then, is an intermediately powering-invariant subgroup of . Explicitly, suppose is a subgroup of containing . Then, is a powering-invariant subgroup of .
Related facts
Facts used
- Torsion-freeness for a prime is subgroup-closed
- Equivalence of definitions of nilpotent group that is torsion-free for a set of primes
Proof
Given: A nilpotent group , a subgroup of that is local powering-invariant and such that where is the center of . A subgroup of containing . A prime number such that is -powered. An element .
To prove: There exists a unique element such that .
Proof:
| Step no. | Assertion/construction | Facts used | Given data used | Previous steps used | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | . | . | given-direct | ||
| 2 | is -torsion-free. | is -powered (we are using the powering-injectivity here) | given-direct | ||
| 3 | is -torsion-free. | Fact (1) | Steps (1), (2) | Step-fact combination direct | |
| 4 | The map is injective in . | Fact (2) | is nilpotent | Step (3) | Step-fact combination direct (specifically, we want to use the implication from (4) to (1) in the multi-part equivalence of Fact (2)) |
| 5 | There exists an element satisfying . | is -powered (we are using the -divisibility here), | given-direct | ||
| 6 | The element of the preceding step is the unique root of in all of . | Steps (4), (5) | Step-combination direct | ||
| 7 | The element of Step (5) is in . | is local powering-invariant in . | Step (6) | Step-given combination direct. |