2-regular group action implies elementary Abelian regular normal subgroup
Statement
Suppose is a finite group with a 2-regular group action on a set . Then, there exists a normal subgroup of such that the induced action of on is a regular group action, and a permutable complement to in . More precisely, is a Frobenius group with Frobenius kernel and a Frobenius complement whose action by is a regular group action on the non-identity elements of .
Facts used
- Frobenius' theorem
- Finite and automorphism group is transitive on non-identity elements implies elementary Abelian
Proof
Given: A finite group with a 2-regular group action on a set .
To prove: has an elementary Abelian regular normal subgroup with a permutable complement whose induced action on by conjugation is a regular group action on the non-identity elements. Further, if has order , then for some prime and positive integer , and the order of is .
Proof: Let be the isotropy subgroup of any element of . The conjugate subgroups of in are precisely the isotropy subgroups of different elements of .
- For any , is trivial: Since , we have . Consider the ordered pair . Since the action of on is 2-regular, we know that the only element of that fix the ordered pair is the identity element. Since and are the isotropy subgroups of and respectively, their intersection must be trivial.
- is a Frobenius subgroup of : This follows directly from step (1).
- The complement of the union of conjugates of in forms then non-identity elements of a normal subgroup of : This follows from fact (1).
- The induced action of on is semiregular: Note that intersects every conjugate of trivially, so acts semiregularly on .
- The induced action of on is regular: Suppose has size . Then, has size , and each of the subgroups has size . There are of these, each with the non-identity elements distinct. Thus, we get a total of non-identity elements in the union of conjugates of , leaving elements for . Thus, acts semiregularly on and has the same size as , so acts regularly on .
- The induced action of on by conjugation is a semiregular group action on the non-identity elements: Recall that is the isotropy subgroup of the element . For non-identity elements , we want to show that . Suppose, for a contradiction, that . Then, we have . Thus, fixes both and , a contradiction to 2-regularlity.
- The induced action of on by conjugation is a regular group action on the non-identity elements: The action is semiregular, and the size of equals the number of non-identity elements of , so the action is regular.
- The automorphism group of is transitive on its non-identity elements: Since acts regularly on the non-identity elements of by conjugation, and conjugation by elements of gives automorphisms of , the automorphism group of is transitive on the non-identity elements.
- is elementary Abelian: This follows from fact (2).
- Conclusion: is an elementary Abelian regular normal subgroup, and acts regularly on the non-identity elements of by conjugation.
- It further follows that since is elementary Abelian, has order . So, and the order of is .