(1,1)-bi-Engel implies second derived subring is in 2-torsion

From Groupprops

Statement

Suppose is a (1,1)-bi-Engel Lie ring, i.e., for all . Then, we have that . More explicitly:

Proof

Given: Lie ring . for all .

To prove:

Proof: Fix for this proof.

Step no. Assertion/construction Facts used Given data used Previous steps used Explanation
1 Lie bracket is linear Polarize the original identity, setting . For , take the values respectively, subtract, and simplify.
2 Lie bracket is skew-symmetric Step (1) In Step (1), use skew symmetry between and .
3 and . Lie bracket is skew-symmetric Use skew symmetry twice within each
4 Lie bracket is linear Identical reasoning as Step (1), letter roles changed: now take . For , take the values respectively, subtract, and simplify.
5 Steps (3), (4) Step-combination direct
6 Steps (2), (5) Step-combination direct