Statement
Original formulation
Suppose
is a group and
is a normal subgroup contained in the hypercenter of
. Suppose
is a prime number such that
and
are both powered over the prime
. Then, the quotient group
is also powered over
.
Corollary formulation
Suppose
is a group and
is a normal subgroup contained in the hypercenter of
that is also a powering-invariant subgroup of
. Then,
is a quotient-powering-invariant subgroup of
.
Facts used
- Upper central series members are normal (in fact, they are strictly characteristic subgroups)
- Normality is strongly intersection-closed
- Upper central series members are powering-invariant
- Central implies normal satisfying the subgroup-to-quotient powering-invariance implication
- Third isomorphism theorem
Proof
Case of containment in a member of the finite upper central series
Given: A group
with upper central series
. A normal subgroup
of
contained in
for some positive integer
. A prime number
such that both
and
are powered over
.
To prove:
is powered over
.
Proof:
| Step no. |
Assertion/construction |
Facts used |
Given data used |
Previous steps used |
Explanation
|
| 1 |
Consider the subgroup series . |
|
|
|
|
| 2 |
Each subgroup of the form , is a normal subgroup of . |
Facts (1), (2) |
is normal in . |
|
Fact-given direct.
|
| 3 |
For any with , is central in . |
|
|
Step (2) (for making sense of quotients) |
We have , and the claim follows.
|
| 4 |
For any with , we have that if is -powered and is -divisible (here, -divisible means every element has a not necessarily unique root in the group), then is -powered. |
Facts (4), (5) |
|
Step (3) |
First note that if is -powered, then any -divisible subgroup must be -powered because of global uniqueness of roots. Thus, is -powered. Step (3) tells us that is central in , hence by Fact (4) and the preceding sentences, we get that the quotient group is -powered. By Fact (5), this is isomorphic to , completing the proof.
|
| 5 |
Each of the subgroups is -powered and hence and are both -powered. |
|
By Fact (3), each is -powered. Combine with the fact that is -powered to get that the intersection is.
|
| 6 |
Each quotient group is -divisible for (here, -divisible means every element has a not necessarily unique root in the group). |
|
|
Step (5) |
This follows directly from Step (5), and the observation that any any quotient of a -divisible group by a normal subgroup is -divisible.
|
| 7 |
For any with , we have that if is -powered, so is . |
|
|
Steps (4), (6) |
Step-combination direct.
|
| 8 |
is -powered. |
|
is -powered. |
Step (7) |
Step (7) and use the principle of mathematical induction, starting from (i.e., is -powered), and inducting all the way till we reach that is -powered.
|