Varying normality

Normality is one of the most pivotal subgroup properties. It traces its origins to the very beginnings of group theory, in fact, to even before that. Given its long history and the varied ways in which it turns up, it is natural that a large number of variations of normality have popped up in group theory.

This article surveys some of the more common among the many variations of the subgroup property of normality, trying to organize them into themes and streams. There are three basic ideas behind variation:

• Emulate the strengths
• Remedy the weaknesses
• Weaken or remove the strengths

Finding right transiters

Lack of transitivity is one of the major problems with normality. One way of remedying this problem is to find transitive subgroup properties $q$ such that every normal subgroup of a subgroup with property $q$ is normal.

All the properties $q$ discussed below satisfy the following:

• Every normal subgroup of a subgroup with property $q$ is also normal
• The subgroup property is transitive
• The subgroup property satisfies intermediate subgroup condition

Transitively normal subgroup

Further information: transitively normal subgroup

The property of being a transitively normal subgroup is the right transiter for the subgroup property of normality. It is defined as follows:

$H$ is transitively normal in $G$ if whenever $K$ is a normal subgroup of $H$, then $K$ is also normal in $G$.

Alternatively, observe that the property of being a normal subgroup can be expressed in the function restriction formalism as:

Quotientable automorphism $\to$ Automorphism

This is a left tight restriction formal expression, and hence the right transiter of normality is:

Quotientable automorphism $\to$ Quotientable automorphism

This is the same as the proeprty of being transitively normal.

Conjugacy-closed normal subgroup

Further information: conjugacy-closed normal subgroup

The property of being a conjugacy-closed normal subgroup is equivalent to the property of being both normal, and conjugacy-closed. A subgroup is termed conjugacy-closed if any two elements in the subgroup that are conjugate in the whole group are also conjugate in the subgroup.

Alternatively, we can view the property of being conjugacy-closed normal as follows.

The property of being normal can be written as:

Class automorphism $\to$ Automorphism

Hence the property:

Class automorphism $\to$ Class automorphism

is stronger than the right transiter of normality. This property is precisely the same as the property of being a conjugacy-closed normal subgroup.

Central factor

Further information: central factor The property of being a central factor is defined as follows: $H$ is a central factor of $G$ if $HC_{G}(H)=G$. Equivalently, observe that the subgroup property of normality can be expressed as:

Inner automorphism $\to$ Automorphism

Thus, the following property is clearly stronger than the right transiter:

Inner automorphism $\to$ Inner automorphism

This is precisely the same as the property of being a central factor.

Direct factor

Further information: direct factor

We know that the subgroup property of being a direct factor is a t.i. subgroup property, and that it satisfies the intermediate subgroup condition. Further, a direct factor is clearly a central factor, hence it is stronger than the right transiter of normality.